Save me a seat on the 'older and pickier' bench. I ended up rereading a lot of favorites this year, but it wasn't really a bad year for reading - just put aside a lot more books then I actually finished.
HF
Bring Up The Bodies (read twice, which meant I had to re-read Wolf Hall twice ....)
Illuminations by Mary Sharrat (a decent imagining of what little is known about the life of Hildegard of Bergen)
Astray by Emma Donague (short stories based on real life characters)
Funny Papers Tom DeHaven (beginnings of the comics in newspapers, turn of the last century)
The Mirador Eliz Gille (novel based on the life of her mother, Irene Nemirovsky)
Non Fiction
In An Antique Land Amitav Ghosh
Memory Castle Mira Bartok
Cartoon History of the World Larry Gonick Vol III (I remember when these came out individually back in the 70s. The author started putting them into complete volumes which are so satisfying. finally got around to this one and found out that there is a 4th volume. Great series.)
Chicken Every Sunday Rosemary Drachman Taylor (memoir about the authors life in Arizona in the early 1900s)
Novels non HF
State of Wonder by Ann Patchett
Turn of Mind by Alice La Plante
The Speed of Dark by Elizabeth Moon
Absolutely loved that book - what happens when a cure for autism is found and all people with autism are required to take it. The meme of what is normal is done so well here.