Welcome to the Historical Fiction Online forums: a friendly place to discuss, review and discover historical fiction.
If this is your first visit, please be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above.
You will have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed.
To start viewing posts, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
If this is your first visit, please be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above.
You will have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed.
To start viewing posts, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
December 2010: What are you reading?
Posted by Ariadne
Glad it's good- I've got it sitting on my TBR pile - who could resist a book about the enigmatic Etruscans? I was initially put off by the cover which didn't speak to me of antiquity at all.Yesterday I finished Elisabeth Storrs' The Wedding Shroud, about the Etruscan civilization circa 406 BC. Review forthcoming on my blog; it's very much worth reading though harder to obtain for non-Australian audiences, unfortunately.
[quote=""Michy""]Yes, everyone mentions getting "hooked" on Dorothy Dunnett -- that, frankly, is the only thing that makes me willing to give her another try. Otherwise, the book would have hit the wall. As you say, the characters constantly spout highfalutin lingo that is over my head!
And someone else mentioned that Dunnett purposely makes her prose "murky" -- apparently she gradually peels back the layers and reveals things to the reader. That appeals to the puzzle-lover in me. So I will give her another go one of these days.....[/quote] I'm taking a second crack at Dunnett's Game of Kings and have made it to page 140.... so far so good.... The dialogue -- particularly Lymond's -- seems to be getting a little less cryptic and the narrative a little less lofty (not so many OTT similes). And I have a fairly good sense of what's going on (always good in a book
), although sometimes I am still feeling a little lost. I know, for instance, that the whole novel is somewhat of an allegory to a chess game, but since I have only a rudimentary understanding of chess that element is going over my head. But I don't think it's really necessary in order to understand the plot (hopefully).
I am now picking up on what I think is her sardonic wit -- although sometimes I just have a sense that she's poking fun at something, but realize that I'm not quite getting the joke (not a nice feeling
). But the very best one so far was when the heavily-lisping Lord Grey said in exasperation, "Ith there no word in the Englith language wanting an Eth?" Which, after reading a entire page of his "th"-laden speech, is exactly what I was thinking! (which was obviously Dunnett's point!)
So I guess this means I'm making progress.
Whether or not I feel she is worth the trouble (she does make her readers work), though, is something I probably can't decide until I've finished the book.


I am now picking up on what I think is her sardonic wit -- although sometimes I just have a sense that she's poking fun at something, but realize that I'm not quite getting the joke (not a nice feeling

So I guess this means I'm making progress.

- MLE (Emily Cotton)
- Bibliomaniac
- Posts: 3565
- Joined: August 2008
- Interest in HF: started in childhood with the classics, which, IMHO are HF even if they were contemporary when written.
- Favourite HF book: Prince of Foxes, by Samuel Shellabarger
- Preferred HF: Currently prefer 1600 and earlier, but I'll read anything that keeps me turning the page.
- Location: California Bay Area
Ha! Love stuff like that.
Now reading Best American Travel Stories 2010. Several of the selections this year are filled with history - Ian Fraziers trip through Siberia includes Russian history in the area (tho in my opinion, the piece was much too long to be included in this collection), and Tom Bissel's story about travels in Israel had much about early Christian history. Good stuff.
Now reading Best American Travel Stories 2010. Several of the selections this year are filled with history - Ian Fraziers trip through Siberia includes Russian history in the area (tho in my opinion, the piece was much too long to be included in this collection), and Tom Bissel's story about travels in Israel had much about early Christian history. Good stuff.
[quote=""MLE""]She has a little byplay where Francis is pretending to be Spanish and describes himself as 'embarasado' which, although from the same root as the English 'embarrassed' has the cultural connotation of 'pregnant'. And the Spaniard gives him a startled look!
[/quote] That was one of the (many) scenes where I knew there were jokes going on, but realized I wasn't getting all of them. I guessed "embarazado" meant "embarrassed", but it was obvious by the characters' reactions that that wasn't what it meant. Thanks for clarifying that.
But who was the actual Spaniard in that scene? I don't remember there being one, I must've missed it. Need to go back and re-read that part......

But who was the actual Spaniard in that scene? I don't remember there being one, I must've missed it. Need to go back and re-read that part......
[quote=""annis""] Glad it's good- I've got it sitting on my TBR pile - who could resist a book about the enigmatic Etruscans? I was initially put off by the cover which didn't speak to me of antiquity at all.[/quote]
It didn't to me either, but that's covers for you. I assume it's meant to represent the decadence to which the main character's exposed. My review of it is up. It's surprising more novelists haven't written about the Etruscans, as their civilization is such a rich vein of material. I know of just one other, Sybille Haynes' The Augur's Daughter, and the author told me one more, Mika Waltari's The Etruscan.
Yesterday night I finished Patricia O'Reilly's Time and Destiny, a multi-period imagined biography of Irish designer Eileen Gray and her life in a bohemian 1920s Paris.
It didn't to me either, but that's covers for you. I assume it's meant to represent the decadence to which the main character's exposed. My review of it is up. It's surprising more novelists haven't written about the Etruscans, as their civilization is such a rich vein of material. I know of just one other, Sybille Haynes' The Augur's Daughter, and the author told me one more, Mika Waltari's The Etruscan.
Yesterday night I finished Patricia O'Reilly's Time and Destiny, a multi-period imagined biography of Irish designer Eileen Gray and her life in a bohemian 1920s Paris.