PDA

View Full Version : Gone with the Wind, Margaret Mitchell


pat
08-26-2008, 12:36 AM
Gone with the Wind, Margaret Mitchell

We have all heard of or seen the classic film with Vivien Leigh as Scarlett O'Hara and Clarke Gable as Rhett Butler, but have we read the novel? We should!

Set in Georgia, USA it tells of the American Civil War and its impact on the citizens of Atlanta and surrounding area.

We read how Gerald O'Hara, Scarletts father, obtains his plantation home in a game of poker, how he decides the home needs a mistress and he gets a wife in the form of Ellen. He builds Tara up making it one of the finest and most respected plantations and homes in the area.

Scarlett, the eldest child was like her father; hot headed, knew what she wanted and got it! She loved Ashley Wilkes from Twelve Oaks, the neighboring plantation, but she was loved by all the beaus in the area! He world crumbled, however, when she found the truth that Ashley was to marry Melanie Hamilton, an marrage that had been arranged for years. In a fit of pique, Scarlett agrees to marry Charles Hamilton, Melanies brother. At the same time, the war was announced, and all the young men rushed off to fight the Yankees. Two months into the war Charles dies, not a heroic death in combat, but of measles. Scarlett in plunged into black as a grieving widow, carrying his son.

Upon the birth of Wade, Scarlett is in depression. Ellen sends her to Atlanta with Wade, to Melanie and Aunt Pittypat, Charles and Melanies elderly maiden aunt. Here, Scarlett casues scandal. Her help in the hospital and other duties were deemed good, but her friendship with Rhett Butler was frowned upon. She had first met Rhett at Twelve Oaks, as the war was declared, there she thought him rude and arrogant. She also came out of mourning too early by the accounts of the busy bodies!

Rhett made his living by running the blockades, not fighting. The townsfolk of Atlanta thought he should be a part of the war, not profiteering from it. However, they did not turn away his bolts of cloth he managed to get through, or other fineries!

As the novel developes, we read about Scarletts torment living with Mellie, her anguish when Ashley comes home and returns to the front. We read how Scarlett delivers Mellies baby, Beau, with the laughable aid of Prissy, her maid. The heroic drive from Atlanta as it falls, back to Tara with Mellie in the back of the wagon having just given birth.

Scarlett finds Tara still standing, only just. Her mother had died, her sisters still very ill, and her father loosing his mind. Her faithful servant Mammy, and Geralds manservant Pork managing to only just hold onto things. Scarlett turns the house around from a crumbling decaying wreck, to a place of hope. The war is delared over, and subsequently Ashley makes his way home.

Scarlett married again for money, returning to Atlanta. Here she ran a buisiness, this was also frowned upon! She had vowed never to be poor again, and Scarlett was doing her best not to be. She sent money back to Tara to help the running of the house, but no one seemed to mind this! All through her times in Atlanta, she kept running into Rhett. When she fell pregnant by her husband Frank, she secured Ashley to work in her business, but continued to be seen about untill her obvious pregnancy was too obvious!

Frank Kennedy was killed because of Scarletts independence. She had gone to see one of the mills, and was attacked. To her aid came a former Tara worker, Big Sam. He returned her to Frank, and, although it was not mentioned there in the book, the Klan sought revenge. Rhett found out it was an ambush. The Yankees were lying in wait for them, and managed to save Ashley, but not Frank. Once again Scarlett was in mourning.

Rhett and Scarlett now come together! At last! They are married against wishes, as Scarlett should still be grieving. From this, Scarlett has another child, Bonnie. The apple of her fathers eye, she can do no wrong! Until....

....if you have not seen the film, you will need to read the book!

It is a shame this is the only novel by Margaret Mitchell, as it is fantastic! I am not a lover of the American Civil War, but the story of Scarletts gutsy approach to life and her determination to never be poor again is so well written.

Does Rhett say the famous line: Frankly my dear, I don't give a damn ?You will have to read it to be sure! As Scarlett says: Tomorrow is another day!

For more infomation:

http://www.gwtw.org/gonewiththewind.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gone_with_the_Wind

A good read! Please try it if you have not!

Leyland
09-02-2008, 04:40 PM
I'm glad I read it again earlier this year. Scarlett and Melanie were a lot closer emotionally than I realized in the sense that Scarlett had more true respect for Melanie's strength and perspective, and relied upon it when needed, than what is portrayed in the movie. I've seen the movie several times of course, but now have read the book only twice.

The true foundation of GWTW to me this time around is this relationship, not just Scarlett's struggle to survive the destruction of her economic resources any way she can. I read it more for the romance the first time - the irresistable lure of the rapscallion versus the longing for the unattainable knight in shining armor. Scarlett's life would have been dramatically different had she not married Charles Hamilton and gained Melanie as a true friend.

Vanessa
09-02-2008, 05:17 PM
One of my most favourite books ever!:D

Misfit
09-02-2008, 05:26 PM
I read this in my teens oh so many years ago and read it again a couple of years ago. I love those books that stand the test of time. The movie was good, but there's so much more in the book.

Michy
05-20-2010, 07:45 PM
I have to weigh in here and say that GWTW is my all-time favorite book. I know, I am soooo unoriginal, but what can I say? :o No other book has so thorougly captured my imagination like this one.

I first read GWTW at age 16, have re-read it a couple of times since then, and will doubtless read it again one of these days. For me, what makes it so magic is not the plot but the people; I have yet to find any other author who can create characters like Margaret Mitchell could. She somehow managed to fill them with such subtleties and complexities that they live on in our imaginations like real people.

I just wish someone would make an audio version of this book on CD. I would LOVE to have an audio version of GWTW, but don't want it on tape (can't imagine how many cassettes that would be.... 70? 100?)

I have never seen the movie -- I don't watch movies -- so I naturally can't draw any comparisons. But I don't see how it could possible compare to the book. How could a movie climb into Rhett's and Scarlett's heads the way the book does? And does the movie go into the backstory of Scarlett's parents and how they got together, how her dad acquired Tara, etc.? Although I do have the music score on CD -- makes nice background music occasionally. :)

MLE
05-20-2010, 08:09 PM
I don't know if it is available on CD yet, Michy, but there is an audio version, and the reader does all the grades of southern accents extremely well. I heard it back in the 90's when audiocassettes were the hot new thing. Although it is only about 50 cassettes, not nearly as long as the Far Pavilions, which I found surprising, since both books have equivalent page lengths and neither audiobook was abridged.

Vanessa
05-20-2010, 08:38 PM
I loved both the film and the book. The film is a condensed version of the book - if I remember rightly it misses out a couple of Scarlett's husbands! For its day, it's quite an epic - the film, that is.

It looks like the audio version can be downloaded onto an ipod or MP3 player via a site like Audible (http://www.audible.com/adbl/site/enSearch/searchResults.jsp?BV_UseBVCookie=Yes&N=0&Ntx=mode%2Bmatchallpartial&D=gone+with+the+wind&Dx=mode%2Bmatchallpartial&Ntk=S_Keywords&Ntt=gone+with+the+wind).

LoveHistory
05-20-2010, 11:17 PM
I've read the book. They did have to cut a lot out for the film but the husbands are there, it's the children who are missing.

Great book. Really good movie. It's one of my favorites for recasting.

Misfit
05-20-2010, 11:22 PM
I've read the book. They did have to cut a lot out for the film but the husbands are there, it's the children who are missing.

Great book. Really good movie. It's one of my favorites for recasting.

I believe you're right, she lost a few kids in the movie. I enjoyed the movie, but it's no where near what you get in the book. It's one of those books you need to read in your teens and then years later when you are really grown up.

That said, I adored Vivian Leigh's one scene in the movie the day after Rhett got drunk and carried her up the stairs. Everything was pretty much left to the imagination - but what she was able to convey about the night past with her facial expressions was priceless. I'm thinking she enjoyed it, a lot ;)

Vanessa
05-21-2010, 08:36 AM
I knew they missed out something!!:o:D LOL.

Well, Clark Gable was a bit of a dish in his day, so I'm not surprised she had a smile on her face! My dad was said to look like him, bless him!

LoveHistory
05-21-2010, 09:34 PM
I believe the book said "he had used her brutally and she had gloried in it."

Gable did a good enough job capturing Rhett's spirit that I don't even mind his lack of a drawl.

Miss Moppet
05-21-2010, 11:04 PM
I recommend Helen Taylor's book Scarlett's Women (http://www.amazon.com/Scarletts-Women-Gone-Wind-Female/dp/0813514967/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1274482983&sr=8-1) for anyone who loves GWTW - all about the GWTW female fandom. Written in the 1980s so a little dated but a lot of fun to read.

Andromeda_Organa
05-23-2010, 08:08 PM
one of my professors said I was a racist for liking this book and movie...

Michy
05-23-2010, 08:46 PM
I'm not going to go into a rant, but I'll just say that I strongly disagree with your professor, and leave it at that. :)

LoveHistory
05-24-2010, 04:13 PM
I won't rant either but I will say that professor is very closed-minded, and very likely an idiot. Many people love the story and I doubt more than a handful are racists.

Racism is not a theme in GWTW. The book is set before, during, and after the Civil War in the state of Georgia. Slavery is an unavoidable background element. Leaving it out would have been irresponsible, and demonstrated a child-like inability to deal with unpleasant realities.

Vanessa
05-24-2010, 04:54 PM
That's definitely not what springs to mind when I think of GWTW. Most people think of it as a romance, actually, but I think it's a lot more than that, too. It's mostly about war and what effects it has on people and the other things are just part of that. Some great characters.

Ludmilla
05-24-2010, 06:02 PM
It's one of those books you need to read in your teens and then years later when you are really grown up.


I agree... I've only read it once and when I was a young teen at that, but have really felt the desire to read it again at some point this year (probably late this summer with an LT group that is reading it in August). My interest has partly been rejuvenated by the fact that I literally live in GwtW territory on land once owned by Mitchell's forebears. I think she would sit down and cry if she could see what suburban sprawl has done to much of the land that inspired her novel and what was once largely agricultural even in her lifetime.

Misfit
05-24-2010, 06:40 PM
I agree... I've only read it once and when I was a young teen at that, but have really felt the desire to read it again at some point this year (probably late this summer with an LT group that is reading it in August). My interest has partly been rejuvenated by the fact that I literally live in GwtW territory on land once owned by Mitchell's forebears. I think she would sit down and cry if she could see what suburban sprawl has done to much of the land that inspired her novel and what was once largely agricultural even in her lifetime.

Oh, you'll be surprised at how differently you react to it, at least I did. I don't see it as racist at all, it's just telling it like it was. I loathe sugar coated history anyway.

Michy
05-24-2010, 07:55 PM
That's definitely not what springs to mind when I think of GWTW. Most people think of it as a romance, actually, but I think it's a lot more than that, too. It's mostly about war and what effects it has on people and the other things are just part of that. Some great characters.
I've heard others denigrate GWTW as being racist -- particularly for the way Mitchell wrote the slaves' speech. But to do that is to judge her book by today's standards, not by the standards or context of the times in which she wrote it.

Hers is not the only book written pre-Civil Rights that treats black slaves in a less-than-flattering way in literature. When I re-read Anya Seton's My Theodosia earlier this year (which was also written pre-Civil Rights) the way she depicted slaves made me squirm.

For those who don't like GWTW because of the slavery, I can't blame them. But as Misfit says, that's the way it was. All I can say is, I just love the book! Not because of the slavery issue, but in spite of it.

I really think that's the way most people feel. For someone to call that racist is totally missing the mark and unfair.

Misfit
05-24-2010, 08:08 PM
When I re-read Anya Seton's My Theodosia earlier this year (which was also written pre-Civil Rights) the way she depicted slaves made me squirm.

Oh, me too. Really hard to take at times but then like I said before......

Michy
05-24-2010, 09:19 PM
In my TBR stack is "The History of White People." I bought this after hearing the author on a call-in talk show on NPR. It is, from what I could tell, a book about the whole notion of slavery throughout history (not just black slavery in America) and it was written by Nell Painter, a black woman. I was fascinated just from the few minutes I was able to catch of her interview, and am looking forward to the book. Hopefully I won't be disappointed (I don't have a great track record with books I've discovered through NPR). :(

If any of you have read it, please let me know what you thought. It will probably be a few months before I get to it.